Question Home

Position:Home>Philosophy> If you were starving to death and the only way to survive was to eat your belove


Question: If you were starving to death and the only way to survive was to eat your beloved pet!?
Would you do it!?
I want you to understand that our survival instincts are greater than affection or love!. Am I wrong!?

Thanks a lot!.Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
Years ago, when my daughter was about 4, I would bring home 'day-old' chickens to raise for [i] egg production, and [ii] meat (the males were allocated that role)!. My little daughter would spend hours daily playing with these chickens!.

"You! Timmy! You're being really naughty today! I'll punish you if you don't behave! Ah, good boy, now!"

"Oh, poor little dear! The naughty big chooks ate your food!. Here's some more!."

She would 'read' stories to them, dress them in her doll's clothing when they became larger!.!.!.!. To say she loved them would be a big understatement!.

Then the evil day arrived!. Yes, the largest of the male chickens would appear on the table, roasted!.

"Oh! Doesn't Timmy taste lovely, Mum!" said healthy, rural-living daughter!.

I doubt that I will ever forget this!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

No I would not!.

I would say you are wrong, that there are plenty of examples of people putting aside their own survival instincts for the sake of affection or love!.

It might be the case though, that there is some other reward that enters the equation to tip the scales toward love and affection so that it wins out over survival instincts!. It could be that self-sacrifice ultimately has selfish roots, and we do it for the reward of feeling good about doing it, or to avoid the punishment of feeling bad about not doing it!.

If altruistic acts created feelings exactly opposite to the ones that they normally do, would we still do them!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

This one has, at different times and in various places eaten many different snakes, sea creatures, dogs, cats, monkeys, lizards, alligators, horse, donkey, camel, rat, humming bird, crickets, ants, garsshoppers, grubs, beetles, termites and other creatures!.

This one would have to consider long and hard about eating a pet so as to save himself as after all, that would be one or possibly two meals and then one would starve to death anyway and that might not be worth the emotional pain and the death of a friend!.

However, if was between feeding this ones daughter and the life of the pet, this one might feel very differently!.

Then the question might be what would this one tell his daughter about the missing pet!?

Be well!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Whoever says no, has never been in a death situation, this certain type of situation!. Look back at the Romantic period!.!.!.This is when cannibalism started erupting!. People do crazy things in crazy situations!. This is my personal belief: Right now I would like to say that no, I would never do it!. But I know that everyone here would in fact, do it!. If the question was, 'If you were starving to death, and the only way to survive was to eat your beloved friend' I STILL think people would do it!. The human body has a survival mode and it resorts to things that we find grotesque in today's society!. There was a study conducted at Harvard University in Spring of 2005, 100 people were asked the question of resorting to eating their family/friends in this situation, time of death!.!.!.if you were stranded on an island type of situation!. Guess what!? 90% of people said they would do it, and 10% said they would do it as well but not if it was their children!. Yea, its very surprising and it shocked me too, but yeah!. Just something interesting I thought you'd all like to know!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

No, I don't believe I could bring myself to kill a friend and furry family member for the sake of a few morsels!. That however is my personal opinion, others may choose to eat!. As far as survival instincts, a man down the road from my aunt had committed suicide in wintertime(keep in mind they lived in the boonies), his body wasn't found until spring!. He had five dogs, all of which were starving, nearly dead and yet they still watched over his body!.!.!.if they didn't choose to survive by eating their master I wouldn't deem it fair for us to eat them!. There is always another way to survive and if there isn't then the time a dog or cats body would give us would be wasted in comparison to our emotional turmoil!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

If this was true, then why are there so many instances where people put themselves in harms way to save the life of another!?
another problem with this is the fact that people don't have the same type of "love" for pets as they do for other humans!. If my pet was my only chance of survival, I would take it!. If the death of another human was my only chance of survival, then I would die!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I rather eat the dirt on the floor I would never eat my little dogie I would starve and die and my little dogie will come with me to the after life once I pass on!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.

If the dogie loves its owner and raises it well it will always be by the persons side :)) even after death :))))Www@QuestionHome@Com

If it were life or death, no possible way to get any food!.

I would eat my rabbit first then 2 dogs!. Before it came down to that I would be foraging in the forrest looking for grubs, or trying to catch a fish, or even eating grass or some other type of vegetation!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

No, I wouldn't!. I'd like to believe that the drive for "maybe just a little further, and I'll find food" would be greater than the necessity to eat loved one!. Of course, there is no way to know for sure unless put in that predicament!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

absolutly no!.
i would never do that!. i would have to slaughter my pet and then cook it, the whole time knowing that it wanted food just as much as i did and stood by me the whole way, i reward it by killing it and eating it for my selfish self!. i dont think so!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Of course i would, it's not like eating a person!.!.!. It's an animal!.
You would be surprised what you could bring yourself to do in a survival situation!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Honestly, I think I would commit suicide than live through the anguish of starving to death!.

As this one saying goes:

"Even the snake-bitten man finds sleep, but not the hungry!."

Www@QuestionHome@Com

No, I would not eat either Prince or Duke!.

YES, you are wrong!.
Survival instincts for ourselves are not stronger than our love for others!.

You're welcome!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

No! Dread no!. I might eat some of their cat-food though!.

If my cats & I were starving to death & the only way we could survive was to eat my legs!.!.!.!.!.we would!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

Well, my cat is a total blubber-ball - all fatty, and rather nasty to eat, I should think!.!.!.but as for our lovely lean pet rats!.!.!.mmmmmmmmmmmmm!.!.!.stir-fried rodents!.!.!.


Hafwen x

Www@QuestionHome@Com

hell no!.!.!.i am not eating my pet!.!.!.pssshhh!. lol!. but seriously!. who does that!? well i am an animal loverWww@QuestionHome@Com

i love my pets too much to eat them!. i would starve and die and then they would probly eat me lol!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Nopers!.!.!.could'nt, would'nt, shouldn'tWww@QuestionHome@Com

I could never! My pets are my furry children!. Besides, I'm a vegetarian!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

BBQed Sparky beats dying any day!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Survival instincts are greater but I don't think I would kill and eat my dog!. Www@QuestionHome@Com

It would depend on whether my pet was going to die soon anyway!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

No, I couldn't!. I love my little dog as if he were my true child!. Could you eat your child, I think not!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

hey!.!.!.i am the pet!.!.go find something or someone else to eat!.!.besides i'm kind of greasy anyhowWww@QuestionHome@Com

Well they do have 4 legs, depends on how fast it runs I suppose!.Www@QuestionHome@Com