Question Home

Position:Home>Philosophy> Is it true that Jesus died for sins even if there is no god?


Question: Is it true that Jesus died for sins even if there is no god!?
Don't mean to ignite a firestorm of controversy (I'm presumptuous) but from a metaphorical standpoint isn't it true that Jesus died for the sins of mankind even if there is no god!. Because many people, including the j-man have died as a result of shifting blame!. Do the summation of human flaws translate into sin, or is no one to blame!.Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
Good morning brother
how are you!?
great question

This is a very Foolish statement used by christains which make no sense of humour jesus christ died for sins of human beings

1 if you an me had gone in a hotel and you had already paid bill,than i not need to pay any bill!.
so if jesus had died for sins of humans than do murder and rape jesus had already give the payment of your sins!.

2 so this is a foolish statement,every one had to pay for there sins either good or bad!.if i will kill anyone i will get punishment not you!.

so jesus died for sins of human beings make no sense of humour!.

god bless you brother and will give you power,beauty and knowledge
all the best for the future brotherWww@QuestionHome@Com

There is no first hand historical record of anyone named Jesus!. Even the early Bible writers (who are equally historically mysterious) disagree on much of what he said and did!. Much of the gospels is interpolated from events long after his purported death (such as the rise to prominence of the Pharisees in 95 AD!.)

The legendary character of Jesus is said to have died for the sins of all mankind!. If God (who is much more plausible,) doesn't exist, you are suggesting the legendary Jesus was delusional!. If a schizophrenic puts them self in harms way to protect the Smurfs, did he really die to protect the Smurfs!?

Someone below missed the phrase " first hand historical record!." Nothing was written about Jesus during his lifetime!. That is what first hand means!. Someone who ACTUALLY KNEW HIM!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

No!.

If there is no God-there is no sin!. I think you're confusing the concept of sin with the concept of morality!. "Sin" is neither right nor wrong, good nor evil!. A sin is an act of transgression against the will of God!.

If there is no God-then there can be no deliberate act of disobedience against Gods commandments
Www@QuestionHome@Com

Happy Hiram there IS a historical record that there was a Man named jesus who was born in Bethlahem!.!. get your facts right!.

and there was even a century old documentation that there was a Crucifixion on the day of wednesday!.

that is out of the question, he did infact exist!. the question is if he IS the son of GodWww@QuestionHome@Com

well no one is to truly blame for Jesus' dying for us!. He was planned on doing it to forgive us and as a sign he cared for us!.

but Jesis dod show signs of being part of God because when he was in the garden before excecution, he was praying to God!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Yes it is true because he had been crusified becauce of our sins and even the says that Jesus died because he wanted to set us free from our sins!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I could jump off a cliff to save the world from its sins!. This doesn't mean that I was right, even if billions of people end up living a life centred around my sacrificial-suicide!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Jesus do die for our sins because He loves us so much that's why He do that, and there is God but "god" of course there is none Www@QuestionHome@Com