| Question Home |
Position:Home>Philosophy> What exists?! Answer please!?Question: What exists!?! Answer please!!? Can anyone give me a flawless, credible and fluently constructed piece of prose answering this question:
"How can I be sure than anything else other than my mind exists!?" Keep this in mind: The physical wold is perceived by the mind, and is therefore a creation of the mind, and as such is subject to hallucination and delusion!. Inferably, based on this, the argument of the physical properties of the world is flawed!. Www@QuestionHome@Com Best Answer - Chosen by Asker: Can one make a flawless argument establishing the existence of anything else besides my mind!? Well, first of all, if you start from the inside you don't really establish the existence of your mind you only establish the existence of your mind at a very limited temporal moment!. How do you know all your current thoughts about your old thoughts are not a delusion!? Descrates dictum, I think therefore i am, only establishes the truth of your mind in the moment it is thought!. All the properties you imagine make up yourself could equally be an illusion!. Not only is the physical world perceived by the mind but so are all the thoughts of the mind reflected on by the mind in a temporal order!. This temporal order could be a delusion of the mind or could be the imagination of the mind!. So you don't have a flawless proof of your mind existing since all thoughts you thought you have had could be an illusion, so you just have a proof of your mind existing in the short temporal moment that you are thinking it's existing!. So let's start over -- The concept "proof" presupposes conscious knowledge!. It presupposes language and your use of language!. It presupposes sometype of existence!. To establish "proof" for existence is flawed to begin with; No one can establish a proof for something that relies on that something!. Any argument you make asking me to prove existence is asking me to find a frame of reference outside of existence to establish a noncircular answer!.!. Existence is an axiom of the reality that can not be proved because you can not falsify it!. You can play games asking for others to prove it to you but since it cannot be proven because it's an axiom of reality I can only point out the practical defects of your position!. Examples: please jump off a very high bridge and let's see how the physical properties of the world affect you!. Existence is a metaphysical axiom of reality that you can not get around but it doesn't tell you anything about the NATURE of reality; only that that it is!.Www@QuestionHome@Com Existence can be verified by observers!. Existence demands proof!. The proof is not subjective!. To say that "I exist" is to leaves open the necessity of proof for it!. It is the challenge of the human mind to apprehend the basis of existence!. One grasps that existence is linked to an observable standard, then links himself to it to prove his own existence!. Individual existence does not stand alone; it cannot maintain itself!. There is a Cause for existence and a reason behind it!.Www@QuestionHome@Com I exist!. I'm not a product of your mind!. I can tell you for sure that everything exists until it doesn't, but our perception of it depends on our SUBJECTIVE reality!. Physical things either exist or they don't!. How we PERCEIVE them is where the reality questions lay!. Hope I've clarified things for you, Neo! Www@QuestionHome@Com |