Question Home

Position:Home>Philosophy> Hypothetical : If you and a group of friends are lost in an inhospitable place .


Question: Hypothetical : If you and a group of friends are lost in an inhospitable place !.!. !.!. !?
!.!. !.!. and all are almost starving to death !.!. !.!. and there is no water !.!. and no food at hand !.!. !.!. but you walk some distance away from the group and find a small animal that died recently !.!. the body still warm !.!. and YOU KNOW that if you eat it you will become strong enough to walk the distance that separates you from an almost certain death or staying alive !.!. !.!. would you still call the others and offer to share the little food with them !?
Remember !.!. !.!. if you share it with others the chances of you staying alive will diminish considerably !.
What would you do !?
Thanks so much !.Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
In most inhospitable places there are numerous types of plants!. Knowing which are edible or inedible would allow me to survive!.
I would extract liquid from cactis and other plants!. Water is more important than food!. People can survive for longer on it!. Even if I ate the little animal and tried to get help I would probably become dehydrated from a lack of water quickly!. I would find a huge cactus (that is edible) and share the liquid with my friends!. I would sleep in a shaded spot under a rock and wait until night for it to cool before trying to get out of this place!. I am assuming that you are talking about a sandy desert like place but I understand that a desert can be any place that is inhospitable including ice frozen land!. The image of a sandy desert seems to pop up automatically in my mind!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

God knows more deep down our every hearts!. we can proved to god that we love him if we can love others too!. well i do believed that no matter how small it was if you ask and pray to God before you will all eat it, God will really blessed it!. well for me, death is a certain thing for all of us and for the real christian believers, death is a gain!. all things will work for good according to His purposed!. if ever i am with that situations, i will still give to all others the food and ask, pray and thanks to God what ever it will be!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I would share it!. Yes, my chances decrease for staying alive, but if each person has an increased chance to make it out alive then that is a higher probability that someone would be able to get help!. If only I ate it then there is only one chance for me to save the lives of others and myself!. But if we all ate, then we all could travel that distance together and support one another in our goal for safety!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

You have to add, you could never get back and save any of them!. Then the answer is simple!. Share the animal and eat the friends!. They'll taste better with a little meat on their bones!.

You'd probably only have to eat one of them to save the rest!. How can that be a dodgy proposition!? X number of lives vs!. one bony fella!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I am traveling to Italy on Friday, please wish plentiful supplies of cafes and eateries, I am unwell and you are frightening me !.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

The group and myself find ourselves there and a source of nourishment is found there!. So we share and let the course of events take it up from there!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Believe it or not I prefer to share with my friends!.!.I prefer to die and not live with the idea that I let down my friends!.!.!.
My friends are precious to me!.!.so I prefer to share
peace!Www@QuestionHome@Com

I'm well I think instinct would have kicked in by then for me,anyways!.I'ed probabley eat it for myself!.Not sure!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I'd share it!. That animal had to get its water from somewhere!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

EAT IT
GET OUT
THEN SEND IN HELPWww@QuestionHome@Com