| Question Home |
Position:Home>Philosophy> Is our so called Free-Will nothing but an illusion?Question: Is our so called Free-Will nothing but an illusion!? Because we all have unique personalities!? You may like green and I may like blue or purple!. Why is that!? We are all unique even if twins are raised in a same environment but they end up with a different personality!. So it's the personality that makes use choose and not YOU!. So where is so called Free-Will!?Www@QuestionHome@Com
Best Answer - Chosen by Asker: Free will is an illusion!. We think that in any given moment we have a choice!. But what we choose to do is what we were meant to do and the only thing we could do based on all of the past that led up to that moment!. The present and the future are not constantly being reinvented but following a logical line from out of the past!.Www@QuestionHome@Com Liking green or blue is not a personality trait!. In terms of free will, you could choose to dislike blue in the same way that you chose to like it!. Being subjective about blue is a choice that you made!. You could also be objective and recognize it is just another color that is comprised of light waves that register in your eyes and brain!. Creating a feeling or emotion for a colour -- blue, is merely creating an attachment to an object (the colour)!.Www@QuestionHome@Com Somehow you have come to see "your" personality as something different from "you!." But your personality is the "you" that you have chosen to be!. You personality is the accumulation of your metaphysical hierarchy, your psychology which by the way is majorly epistemic, and it is also simply the way by which you choose to allow your emotions to affect--for good, bad, or otherwise--your psychology!. Or it could be said that personality is the effect of how you allow your metaphysics to mix with your emotions!. Do you see how I keep referring it back to your "choices"!?Www@QuestionHome@Com I often ask myself, does the brain control the being, or does the being control the brain!? And i can honestly say that i don't know!. You may be fast to say, "well of course the being controls the brain, I make the decision to get out of bed, not my brain!." But who decides when you wake up!? Who decides what you dream about!? And don't tell me that everything you do you think is right!. I know that you sometimes do things without thinking them through, and regret them later!. I don't know, just think about it, you would be nothing without your brain, but would your brain be nothing without you!? So I think you should look deeper then the question "So it's the personality that makes use choose and not YOU!?" I think you should look at what makes our personality, then figure it out from there!. Why do I love the color green!? Why do I like rainy days!? Why do I love art!? Who knows right!? I sure as hell don't!. Just think about it!. Great question by the way!. It really gets you thinking!.Www@QuestionHome@Com Free will is not an illusion!. It is simply the name we give to an inner experience we all share -- that of making choices and knowing we could have done otherwise!. If some of us have a tendency to make different choices from others, that doesn't refute the freeness of the choices!. It's just a tendency!.Www@QuestionHome@Com I agree with the second answerer, your personality is you!.Www@QuestionHome@Com http://cogitoswords!.blogspot!.com/2008/06!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com SIMPLE!. WILL POWER IS FREE TO USE!. JUST BE CAREFUL TO CREATE THE EFFECTS YOU WANT WHEN YOU USE IT!.Www@QuestionHome@Com I beleive so! I really think there is no such a think called free will!Www@QuestionHome@Com |