Can emotion be as valid as a reason?

Question: Can emotion be as valid as a reason!?

Provide an example of some sort of how Emotion can be as valid as a reason; if you think other wise!. Tell me how emotion can't be as valid as a reason!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:

This depends a good deal on what you're talking about!. In some instances I'd be inclined to say emotion is equally as valid as something like reason so long as reason isn't disbanded entirely!. It's sort of like a system of checks and balances, we cannot act purely on reason for fear of becoming cold mechanical sacks of chemicals and cannot act purely on emotion because we could not exist within society as nothing more than a bundle of emotions without considering consequences or other possible actions one could take!. You can't live purely on either!.

Many philosophers have ideas on the subject!. John Stuart Mill and Immanuel Kant both thought our actions should be governed purely by logic and reason, Mill thinking we should act for the consequences, Kant thinking we should act on what he called a Categorical Imperative!. David Hume's moral philosophy conversely centered on the idea that we should act in a way that promotes good feelings or emotions!. I highly encourage you to read about these philosophers as well as John Rawls who had equally interesting ideas on the subject!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

and who said reason is valid!?

reason is using the information you already have, "already have" and probably the "only you have" this alone could make you ask reason's credibility!. reason is just judging the answer only from the information provided, thats why it can never be really true!. emotion on the other hand works on a higher level, its the same as reason in a way but more complex, its about being hyper sensitive to your sorroundings!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Emotions ARE reasons!. We do things because of our reasons!.

Example I'll break up with that girl or guy because he/she cheated on me!. The underlying emotion is in the nature of I FEEL I deserve better!. I FEEL I've been treated unfairly!. I FEEL stressed by the situation!. I FEEL I can't trust him or her not to hurt my FEELINGS!.

And those are all the reasons we decided to break up; and we wrap all those emotional reasons into the pack called "he/she cheated on me"!. Ergo, emotions are reason in and of themselves!. And they are valid reasons!.

Untimately, while the emotions are valid, none of the reasoning, or it's use as a reason is actually true!. Those who are able to remove the emotions from the reasons used for their decision-making, tend to be more objective, and are able to produce more effective results!. That's why people who can make decisions without having their judgement "clouded" by emotions tend to be prized and rewarded by our society!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

if the world were an illusion where people believed different things none of which were necessarily true, following your emotion and desire to create a reality and meaning can be just as valid as following some rigid framework of logical reason!.

Depending how deep our logic goes, (and a new sucker is born every minute and must learn), some could use logic or reason to say that look at all this black crime i see, logically black people must be bad!. Jews have all this money and we're poor, they must have cheated us!. These kinds of logical inferences that may not be true!. You may say, ''well the logic is faulty!." People have faulty logic, on a busy street corner another will be by any second!. Who are we to think our logic is so great!? That we're not pushing for an agenda!. That we know the answers or are not working with false premises!.

Logic is used to justify wars and confuse our minds!. Someone in China used to tell me; when I would make these 'clever' manipulations of logic!. Little inferences to get what I want, she would say, "you are very clever" kind of sarcastic and clever in her own way!. This is how i think of logic sometimes, oh that's very clever, you almost fooled me!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

You mean like when someone says, "I'm Tired" when you ask them what's wrong!? I suppose so since an emotion is a physical change and therefore could possibly be a disability!. I think you do need to be more specific as to what kind of reason though!. Because in some situations I could say, I'm angry at you, that's why I'm not talking to you!. But not, I'm angry at you, that's why I blew up the country!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Reason is forming conclusion based on information!. It is possible that your conclusions are wrong!. If you are reasoning logically, then you're conclusions are more likely to be correct!.

There is nothing I know if that would cause an emotional decision to be more correct than a logical one!.

There are always counter examples for any valid point, however using logical reasoning should yield more accurate conclusions because it is designed to do just that!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Emotions are not intellectually based nor rational!. Emotions are conditioned response that are chosen not learned!. Reason involves the development of the intellect which attempts to serve practicality!. If all segments of society were emotionally based rather than based on reason, society would be in a very critical state!. Imagine, elected officials, doctors, corporations, the law and justice systems being based on emotions!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Emotion is an experience and the vehicle that motivates reason!.
In molecular terms emotion is a chemical!.
These chemicals are processed in the limbic system and this is where the experiential sensation of emotion is manifest!.
Thus emotion is a part of reasoning despite common misconceptions!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I will echo mtheoryrules!.!.!. emotion drives reason!.But most people think of them as opposites!.But opposites should always be held together to form a third thing!. Our reasons for everything are always driven by our emotions!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

What does it mean to be as "valid" as reason!? Relevant to what!? Emotional is less 'valid' when doing arithmetic, but perhaps more 'valid' when having sex!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Famous philosophers state that emotion is rooted at all evils and reason develops from goodness!.

So, what would you take from that!? Are good and evil both valid!?

I don't see why not!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Emotions are motivators just like anything else!. The extent to which we control them and how we act upon them is what's really important!.

DougWww@QuestionHome@Com

Great question!, for me the two need to be combined for meaningful reasoning!. But hey what do I know!?Www@QuestionHome@Com