Position:Home>Philosophy> Does this theory hold water?
Question: Does this theory hold water!?
I have a theory that God exists but cannot interact within the time frame with which humans live because the probability of any entity which exists indefinitely existing within one frame of time nears zero, therefore God has no bearing on our physical yet still exists just as if we would exist if we could inhabit a fourth dimension where we experience all of our possible pasts and futures simultaneously!. Its like the probability of choosing one marble out of an infinite series of marbles!.
Note: Don't simply answer God can do anything or something to that effectWww@QuestionHome@Com
Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
No!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
The premise of the theory is that there is a separate singularity outside of everything else in the universe and its dimensions!. Basically, something outside of reality living and interacting with reality!.
It looks like a western mechanical world view where a super magical man existed before reality and built reality like a clock in which all 'life' lives within as separate isolated objects!.
It holds water in that a large portion of the earth holds that world view!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
No, it doesn't really!. Firstly, you provide no logical basis for your assertions!. They appear to be mere guesses!. And secondly, the existence you describe is in practice indistinguishable from nonexistence!. If god exists exclusively in your hypothetical fourth dimension and doesn't interact in any way within our time frame, then in what meaningful sense can we, with only three spatial dimensions, consider him to exist!?
I can't prove that your god doesn't exist, because you say yourself that there is no interaction!. Yet for the same reason, in every practical sense he might as well not exist!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
Water is leaking all over the place!. God would then have never had anything to do with us or our creation because he never could have entered that one "frame" of time to give us that spark of life!. With that in mind, we don't need a God to exist, which means there is a greater probablity that there is no God!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
Wow!. You have given this a bit of thought!. However, the Bible speaks frequently of God appearing to people, parting the Red Sea, etc!. Something would have had to have changed since Biblical times for your theory to hold water!.Www@QuestionHome@Com
No!. I doubt you know what you're admittedly rambling about!.Www@QuestionHome@Com