If the arguments are flawed, does that mean that you have to change the entire p

Question: If the arguments are flawed, does that mean that you have to change the entire philosophy!?
Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:

In "Philosophical Explanations," Robert Nozick discusses that question and says that philosophers often want to have their entire philosophy be deducible from a few basic axioms, creating a "tower" of logic, in which each "brick" rests upon a more fundamental one!. The problem is, if something happens to a brick near the bottom, the entire tower falls, and you must start over!.

He suggests that the model should not be a tottering tower, but the Parthenon: with several columns, any one of which may fall, but something of beauty and strength will remain!.

It is an argument for philosophical pluralism!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Live by your philosophy, but remain open to other ideas!. A flawed argument does not necessarily mean a flawed philosophy!. A flawed argument means that you lack information!. Do your research and listen to the opinions of others whether you agree with it or not!. The more knowledge you have the stronger your argument may be!. The only time you should change your philosophy is when that philosophy no longer fits with or agrees with your lifestyle!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I think sometimes one can proffer flawed arguments about a philosophy that is actually sound!. For example, one might introduce a post hoc (after, therefore because of) argument in favor of a particular philosophical concept!. Although the argument is clearly flawed, the philosophy itself might not be!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

`Oh, heck no!.!.!.some may differ with this opinion, but I believe arguments that may contain some flaws can inspire one to "weed out" the stumbling block misgivings of an otherwise sound philosophy!.!.!.to throw away a whole batch of apples because one or two are rotten is rather foolish and impractical!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Depends upon the argument!. If the argument supports the weight of most of the philosophy, then definitely!. But if it's simply of cursory importance, then you just have to edit it slightly!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

if the arguments are flawed, you do not have to change the philosophy, simply the perspective as well as the reasoning and motif behind the questioning!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

There are so many philosophies!.!.!.why not just walk over to Socrates or Nietzsche and ask them if they want a spot of tea or a brandy!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

Yes!

A sound argument is literary the whole purpose!. Unless one doesn't mind living falsely!.Www@QuestionHome@Com