Was Heisenberg certain about his Uncertainty Principle!?

Question: Was Heisenberg certain about his Uncertainty Principle!!?
Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:

I think you just found a loophole that blows the principle out of the water!. The principle, itself, isnt guaranteed to be applicable!.

To be honest, I think the principle is stupid!. I dont know much about quantum physics, but it seems to me that physicists merely admitted ignorance on the quantum realm!. Saying they cannot compute or predict behavior says nothing about whether or not it actually is predictable!. I think, one day, we will have all the rules of the quantum world written down, too!.!.!. it will be as certain as Newtonian physics - just different!. For the time being, we lack the understanding and technology to measure what we need to in order to understand how predictable it actually is!. Saying "its unpredictable" or "its probabilistic" is really just saying "we havent yet seen a pattern"Www@QuestionHome@Com

Let's use an analogy Heisenberg himself used to describe what the principle was so we're talking about the same thing here!.!.!.

If you had something sitting out in space and wanted to know information about it, one way you might get it is by trying to deflect photons off it (like a blind person rolling pool balls across a table)!.

An individual photon has a wavelength that is related to the energy of the particle inversely!. High-energy particles (like x-rays) have a very small wavelength and low-energy ones (like radio waves) have a very long one!. This is an intrinsic property of the waves!.!.!. you can't have both low-energy AND small wavelength!.

So if you want to get a picture with a high resolution, you'd want to use the smallest wavelength possible!. That let's you tell the difference between things that are close together!. But when you finally hit that thing you're looking for, that particle is going to zing off it and change it!. The particle is going to move in a different direction and with a different speed because of the energy transferred!. And because you used a really small wavelength it has a lot of energy to make that change!. Small uncertainty in position means a large uncertainty in momentum!.

If you try to make sure you don't disturb the object you're looking for, you'll use a really big wavelength instead!. But because the wavelength is so big, it will be really hard to know anything about the exactly location (like using beach balls instead of pool balls)!. Small uncertainty in momentum means a large uncertainty in position!.

Now look at all that!. Is there really a way that this could turn out different!? The Uncertainty Principle doesn't say that that thing we're looking at doesn't have an exact position or momentum!.!.!. just that we can't know them both exactly at the same time!.

When Heisenberg first formulated this idea, he didn't even say what degree of uncertainty that was, just that it must be there!. And he held his position even though the most brilliant and famous minds of his day argued against it (such as Einstein and Popper)!. So yes, I'd say he was pretty darn certain!. And we have certainly found little enough to dispute this principle even now!.

Hope that helps!Www@QuestionHome@Com