My friend said "How can we be here unless God made us?" I asked "

Question: My friend said "How can we be here unless God made us!?" I asked "How could God be unless someone made him!?"How

come she turned red and just looked at her feet!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:

because your friend was raised to be a closed minded religious person!. She is not a freethinker and cannot see outside of her box!. When you showed her her own ignorance, she was possible embarrassed!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Imagine a turning machine producing "round" components!. If you keep on improving the machine towards perfection, the products will be of improved roundness!. And an almost perfect turning machine could produce almost perfect roundness part!.

So, if God, being perfect, produce things (humans and other life forms) so far from perfect!? If God, being all-knowing, could not know that Satan would rebel against him, and even the Archangel (Satan) was not perfect, that was why he needed to rebel against God, can you not see the contradiction!?

Since God is against evil, then how could evil spawn in the ever perfect creation of God!? If Satan and his hordes of angels were not perfect, would everlasting life in "Thy Kingdom come" be perfect!? Then, the billion souls waiting for that would be disappointed, and more rebellions may occur!. What is perfection in afterlife, that you get to bond with all the prettiest beings in heaven!? If there is such a need, can we say that you find perfection in heaven!? If, there will not be such a need, can you say that all have become as great as God, in attaining perfection!? Any of these answers will contradict one another!
The natural order of things is god!. As the smallest particles combine, through the passage of billions of years (after the Big Bang), some life forms could result from habitable conditions!. Permutations through great periods of time, may give rise to more intelligent beings!. And the more intelligent beings, not sure in the design of the universe, question its own existence!. Could its existence came about through a greater force!? The intelligent being hopes for eternity - and that could be attained, IF there is a greater being!. Not knowing the answer, self-delusion is the best way to give oneself a path towards salvation!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Nobody likes to look like an idiot!.

There are religious types who will answer your question with the standard "Nobody he is and always has been"!.

So I say "There was nothing absolutely nothing and that nothing got bored and created everything"!? Remember God created the planets and suns so there really was nothing but God before creation!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Your friend is just exploring her relationship with god with you and asking questions about her ideas of god!. This is actually a good thing since many other religious types tend to not even ask questions, but rather preach and provide answers all the time!.

Her reaction is very good, it seems she is doubting, but I don't think she will leave her relationship with god, but it is important she asks questions!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

because yahoo! answers is a place where people can sit around and bask in their brilliance and crush people in the fist of logic without even examining any arguments, because generalizations reign supreme whenever religions are discussed, particularly Christianity!. Bravo for reciprocating closed-mindedness!.!.!. i've learned a great deal about pseudo-clever arguments and finger-pointing!.!.!.

she turned red and looked at her feet because, yes, there are things we do not know!.

we all have things we don't know!.!.!. like where the little speck of dust that turned into the universe that had a single planet with a primordial soup that turned into life came from!. the little speck of highly condensed matter is as much a mystery as God,

and more a farce than God ever would be!.

what is improbable about God is that he loves people who hate him with every fiber of their being, just like you guys!.!.!. enough to give his son for you!. isn't that amazing!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

Because you hit a nerve with her, probably voicing one thing that has concerned her too!.

I would caution you not to meddle with her faith in her God - question her on her beliefs, yes, but don't dissuade her from what she has faith in!.

Belief must be ready to answer the question "Why!?"
Faith is knowing the validity of your convictions without needing to ask "Why!?"Www@QuestionHome@Com

god is the attempt of a weak mind to explain what it has too much difficulty with explaining Superstitiuos thinking is one of the lowest of all forms of thinking!.
The idea of asking why god has no creator is embarrassing for it assumes foolishly that there is a god in the first place!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

well the teacher asked us once when i was about 11 if we beleived in god and why!. And all of the kids kept saying stuff like!. HOW DID WE GET HERE!? How did the Trees and animals get here!? How did the Ocean etc etc And I yelled out HOW DID GOD GET HERE!?!!!!!!!! And my Science teacher said !.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.YES YES>>>>>>>>>>>> and pointed at me with a very serious and satisfied look on his face One kid said HE ALWAYS WAS HERE!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.Well guess WHAT !.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.that is how I feel about EVERYTHING that it was always here in one form of understnding or another and it is the MIND that is LINEAR !. When we discovered long ago that the world was not FLAT!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.we should have gotten the implications!. That which seem LINEAR are really SPHERICAL with no begining point moving in a straight line to an ending somewhere!. Its all ONE all HERE and NOWWww@QuestionHome@Com

If some other being made god than the present God would not be God!. Unfortunately we have not found evidence of another being stronger than God!. And for that matter some people have a struggle with proving this one even exists!. I myself do believe in this one!. Later!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

I agree!. I would reply with a similar question!.
I'll paraphrase say what I would ask!.
"We are here because God made us!." One says!. To which, I reply, "The idea of God exists because someone before you thought it!."
Is "God" responsible for the idea that founded him!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

God is eternal!. He has no need for cause!. He is outside of time and the universe he created!. Its hard for our limited mind to comprehend this!.

Isaiah 55:8-9
"For My thoughts are not your thoughts, nor are My ways your ways," declares the Lord!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Don't argue with a relgious person, they will never changed their views and they will never admit that they're wrong!. They just continue blindly believe whatever nonsense that has been made up to make life seem more meaningful!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Because she hasn't been brainwashed enough to come up with the typical religious answer - "God has just always been!." or something along those lines!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Either God just appeared out of the blue and made everything!.!.!.

or everything just started and here we are millions of years later,Www@QuestionHome@Com

im answering with a question

http://answers!.yahoo!.com/question/index;!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

It's the same question as Which came first, the chicken or the egg but posed differently!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Cause she was frustrated with your small thinking!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Because she doesn't have any answer!.

God is a farceWww@QuestionHome@Com

How can you ask tht!?Www@QuestionHome@Com