Question Home

Position:Home>Philosophy> Do you think all answers deserve to get thumbs up.............?


Question:...........regardless if you like their contribuition or not?


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker: ...........regardless if you like their contribuition or not?

Yes. Because what we think is a bad answer may for others be a fantastic answer! Where we might like what we write others might hate it. We should give thumbs up to people because that might just make their day!

Only if the answer acutally satisfies the question.

No, I do not.

If you want to farm points, then yes, all answers deserve to get thumbs up as well as a best answer.

Not all answers are right, and some answers on here are either completely irrelevant or ludicrous.

No because sometimes the answer is totally wrong. As in it might lead the person who asked the question to the wrong decision.

No. I give thumbs up depending on how thoroughly the question was answered, wit involved, and honest answers. I don't thumbs down people unless their answer has nothing to do with the question or is completely wrong.

i didnt even notice they had that!!!

Nooo.... for pete's sake there are some (stupid) answers that deserve kicks instead of thumbs down regardless of their intention xD

no because some people put no time or effort into the question. some people dont even answer the question. and some people give awful advice!!!

no

i would never give a "2 points" answer a thumbs up

No, some don't even answer the question, some are hostile, racist , etc. the list goes on.

If it's an answer I think is good in relation to the question being asked, I give a thumbs up, if I feel the answer is out of line, I give a thumbs down and if it's bad enough I report it. If it's a good answer that I don't agree with I do nothing.

Of couse not! Some are not even close to an answer the asker is looking for and some have missed the point entirely. The ones that are, or could be, helpful deserve a thumbs up but certainly not all.

I do give a thumbs down real quick, though.! The ones that are downright snotty and nasty. I've read some that call the asker stupid.

No, I recently got two responses to a question I asked and I gave them both thumbs down because both of them suggested I search for something I was looking for in places I stated I already had searched in the question.

I gave them both thumbs down for stupidity.

Only if the answers deserve one 6(^-^)9

Those people who give lame answers like "Yes" or "No" just to get the points obviously don't deserve it.

No. Especially those that insult the asker, or do nothing more than copy and paste from some website, when others go out of their way to give thoughtful, intelligent answers. People who spend time giving a legitimate answer, regardless of their opinion and whether it conflicts with yours, sure, deserve a thumbs up for taking the time to answer, and giving some consideration to your question. Not everybody cares about points.
Gray fox, that's a great suggestion. Vote "Thumbs down" or a vote to "Kick it out!" Maybe they could have a little jackass avatar or something.

I agree with Sarah.

Well put!

One thumbs up from me.

no, only mine. what other answer could i give? just joking, you choose the comment you agree with and make up your own mind. if you donnot agree you can voice your opinion at any time, i would like to hear it. ok?

No. I don't think so.
I only rate those i feel deserve to be or i agree with or disagree with.
some answers are not worthy rating or are totally out of the point..
Good question.

No not all, but the ones that have some logic even if they go against your own concept.