Question Home

Position:Home>Philosophy> Need help about chained arguments! University Philosophy Students!?


Question:Write the following argument in standard form, in a way which identifies any sub-arguments it may contain and shows how those sub-arguments are chained:

Jim will not be pleased with his final grade for PHL 1010. That is because he needs to study the Reason and Argument component of PHL 1010 in order to pass his exam in that subject, and he is not doing that. This means he will not do well on the exam.


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker: Write the following argument in standard form, in a way which identifies any sub-arguments it may contain and shows how those sub-arguments are chained:

Jim will not be pleased with his final grade for PHL 1010. That is because he needs to study the Reason and Argument component of PHL 1010 in order to pass his exam in that subject, and he is not doing that. This means he will not do well on the exam.

To pass PHL 1010 requires the study of Reason and Argument.
Jim is not studying Reason and Argument.
Jim will not be pleased with his final grade because Jim will not pass PHL 1010,
The major term is PHL 1010.
The middle term is Reason and Argument.
The minor term is Jim will not pass or be pleased.
The standard order of terms in the conclusion is minor/major.

Jim's starting mental state is demotivating because of his grade, this demotivated state discourages him to apply himself to what is vital to making a good grade - the reason and argument chapter. He has created a self-fulfilling prophecy for himself by thinking he is going to fail philosophy.