"No True Scotsman..." (continued below)?

Question:Re - the famous analogy about "The True Scotsman" - is it not perfectly accurate to say;

"No True Scotsman could be a Mexican who's never left Mexico, who's never heard of Scotland, who has no Scottish genes or nationality"

Therefore if he put a kilt on and danced a highland jig, you STILL could legitimately say to him "No true Scotsman would be a Mexican" (c) UK sense ;)

If you are not familiar with this analogy don't waste your time by answering "Errr, i have no idea what you're on about mate". Instead simply go answer an easier question :)

Best Answer - Chosen by Asker: Re - the famous analogy about "The True Scotsman" - is it not perfectly accurate to say;

"No True Scotsman could be a Mexican who's never left Mexico, who's never heard of Scotland, who has no Scottish genes or nationality"

Therefore if he put a kilt on and danced a highland jig, you STILL could legitimately say to him "No true Scotsman would be a Mexican" (c) UK sense ;)

If you are not familiar with this analogy don't waste your time by answering "Errr, i have no idea what you're on about mate". Instead simply go answer an easier question :)

Am I a true Scotsman? A big line in my family has the surname Townsend.

I know for sure I'm Irish due to the Dunagin in me.

The origins of your body have no bearing on who you are