Question Home

Position:Home>Philosophy> Can God create a stone so heavy that even He can not lift it?


Question:Well... can he/she?


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker: Well... can he/she?

Haha! Old question. This link may be helpful: http://www.apath.org/godstone.html

god will never see some things that we can see every sunset or sunrise is twice as beautiful to us because we may never be here again in that comes the grasp to life can he force us to let go of it or treat it as anyless sacred to ourselves dont know

What happens when an irresistable force meets an immovable object? It is a logical contradiction as your question is. God can only do what is in his nature and logically possible. God cannot do evil, make square circles, nor destroy himself. He is only all-powerful in the sense that he can do all possible things.

Personally i come from the What the Bleep Do We Know school of thougt so do not believe in an actual 1 God. But in the belief that atoms have made us all or you may call it "nature" our bodies and the rest of the auniverse is all made from the same atoms and are just putting themselves together in different ways. So the rock can be as big as they want o create it. ;D

weight, length ,and even motion are relative values that relates to rules created by god for 4 dimentions as for god he is cabable of doing things beyond the lows as lows are gods creation ..... in one simple word .. the answer to your question is
NO !

That would be flawed because God is the ultimate of ultimate beings and he can create and destroy in any magnitude. Its like asking the question, Can God create a being more powerful that itself? The answer must stay YES to prove that all truth does have a starting point, a FACT, an absolute and undenyable truth.

Since stones are mass and God is not, the question of lifting a stone does not apply. Can He create a stone that he cannot MOVE is a more valid phrasing of the question. The answer is no.
There are too many ways to move a mass using the existing forces of nature (which God created).

My dear,it seems you are well acquainted with God.By the way,who is God?Answer and get your answer!Jokes aside,I have taught this kind of dispute to thousands of students,but the logic is that it can never be resolved.Bless you.http://www.raja-students.blogspot.com

Okay, we know the bible claims "God is all-powerful"?
Right, if this was indeed true, then god could NOT create a rock he can't lift. Therefore God is not all powerful and we must conclude that either bible is wrong or God is not all powerful.

God is nothing but an extravagant myth perpetuated by obtuse morons who need easy answers and elementary conventions by which to lead their pathetic otiose lives.

"It is far better to grasp the Universe as it really is than to persist in delusion, however satisfying and reassuring." - Carl Sagan

well indeed he did, and he was so disappointed for it wasnt rock, but of a flesh, he sent his angel to teach this guy to be productive, he said to this angel teach this rock to be productive! and so the angel did, but this man was so stubborn because he was a philosopher, he said to god's angel why be productive if I have stock's? well the angel replied, get your money from the stock market and put it in the land in connecticut or virgina!!! why would i do tha?? coz GOD commands you!!! but the philosopher replied if god commands me that why in virgina??? the angel couldnt reply, so god send another angel, please sir, buy lands in connecticut or virgina! for god commands you! why would I do that?? you see this ciggarettes, yes why?? you smoke right?? well yes so?? well sir all you do is smoke and wait for your money in the stock market o why not get your money in the stock market and invest in the tabacco industry!!! well why would I do that when theres money already coming in?? the angel couldnt reply! so god sent lucifer himself! and lucifer cried out! for christ sake pick urself up and be productive for your on borrowed time and you cannot argue with God that you have money in the stocks! plant for crying out loud, make use of your hand, for god sees you and your lame in his eyes, make the land productive so may youreap the benifits of the land, and so may others benifit from you! watch porn so that you make heirs to this land, and may benifit from its fruits. see oyur greed exceeds you, you smoke and benifit from the land yet you dont toil the soil and you dont have children and no people benifit from you or your arrogance!!! if I dont get your butt off that lazyboy the lord of this land will come himself and turn you to stone!!!the philosopher was stomped!!! next day he turned to stoned as lucifer said so!!! moral story is were all on barrowed time!!! make use of it!!! God will come next!!!

Yes. But then he'd just have Chuck Norris lift it for him.

That reminds me of the Simpsons episode!

Homer was reading a joke on a popsicle stick that he was reading to Flanders. It said something like "Could Jesus microwave a burrito so hot that he himself could not eat?"

LOL.

The stone is a part of him/her. God is no the stone, the stone is but a tine peice of God, if of course it is considered with EVERYTHING else.

By the way God actually makes sense to exist in two realities at once. It like it you, person living in the universe, were also the universe that you lived in. GOd is the multverse. The multiverse beign male overall, and the personified form beign female

Might seem like it if it is your kidney stone!

He already did, he created the earth and all of us in it.