Question Home

Position:Home>History> Was the holocaust a lie?


Question: Was the holocaust a lie!?
i saw on tv this guy took samples of concrete and soil at concentration camps and where there should have being traces of chemicals and gas he found nothing and there were no holes for gas to have being pumped in to the shower rooms only water Www@QuestionHome@Com


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker:
Im sure there was mistreatment, hell, it was a war and every country mistreats people at some time!.

The whole thing is just a billion dollar industry made out by you know who!. Money comes first to some people!

It is heavily exaggerated, and should be forgotten about!. It happened over 60 years ago!.!.!. who cares now, let it go!.

Did you know the communists killed much much more people!? Never makes the news, or no movies have ever been made about that!? Hmmmm, I wonder why!?Www@QuestionHome@Com

The Holocaust happened!. The death camps which used mass gassing only occurred at a few camps, there were other camps which were just concentration camps which were used for slave labor, so you naturally would not find evidence of chemicals or gas in those locations!.

The only LIE about the Holocaust, which is perpetrated by radical jews(yes there are radical jews, just like radical christians and muslims) is that the Holocaust was ONLY about the killing of Jews!.

The Holocaust was the systematic torture and killing of some 12 million Europeans by the Nazi Government!. These 12 million or so included French, Dutch, German, Polish, Russians, Gypsies, Slavs, homosexuals, and the retarded!. The number of Jews killed is believed to be between 4!.5 million and 5!.8 million, but while the Jews were the largest portion of the Holocaust, the lying about them being the ONLY part, diminishes the horrors perpetrated on all of the rest and their dignity demands that they be remembered in history alongside the Jews!.

whale

Kitty, while we are at it!.

People who hate Jews are NOT anti-Semitic!. Judaism is a religion, it is not a race of people, propagating that fallacy only engenders hatred!. Semitic means being of the Semite Race, which includes Hebrews AND Arabs!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

No!. The Germans were very good record keepers and kept excellent records about those who were condemned to the gas chambers!. Further, the Nazis were not ashamed of what they did and many confessed to the Holocaust!. Finally, at the end of the war, Allied troops captured the concentration camp and found the ovens and found the starving inmates!. Only an idiot would believe that the Holocaust did not happen!.!.!.!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

This question has appear so many times and in various guises that I was just going to pass it by until I read the answer of Kcuf!. I then read his bio to see if I may be misinterpreting his answer and it appears I wasn’t misinterpreting it!.

That people today question that this ever happened, or that people minimize it, is beyond comprehension!. While other countries have had other mass killing of millions of people (certainly Russia as well as Pol pot in Cambodia and the Kurdish in Northern Iraq and currently in the Sudan, all recorded and reported for those who will seek it) the holocaust in Germany is likely the most detailed in the recording of such events!.

Clearly most of the reporting and writing has been of the Jews, they were certainly not the only ones so treated!. This began in the mid 1930s on orders directly signed by Hitler (they still exist) and were directed at ridding Germany of the aged, physically lamed and the mentally incompetent!. The methods of doing this (mostly starvation) were slow and not efficient and from this evolved the method gassing and burning!. All of this fits the writings of Hitler in Mein Kampf which I highly recommend that anyone who wants to comment on these events first read!.

None of this is a maybe, or a what if, or derived from conclusions drawn from hazing memories or incomplete records, but from complete and detailed records!. For example, The Nuremberg Trials were a series of trials most notable for the prosecution of prominent members of the political, military, and economic leadership of Nazi Germany after its defeat in World War II and here much was documented of the Holocaust!.

From a personal perspective, relatives of mine were among Americans who liberated many of the camps and we still have photographs (in the family) of what they saw!. In addition, I’ve work with people who lived through those camps and still have the tattoo identifications on their arms!. But all thet pales before the evidence of Germany itself, as the following article demonstrates, that is, nearly all of these deaths and the treatment of these individuals was meticulously recorded by the NAZIs and such records are available to the world!. By the way, while it was about 6,000,000 Jews killed in these camps, more than 17,000,000 died or became slaves of the NAZIs in these camps and in the factories!.

WASHINGTON, April 18, 2006 — Germany agreed today to allow access to a vast trove of information on what happened to more than 17 million people who were executed, forced to labor for the Nazi war machine or otherwise brutalized during the Holocaust!.
The German government announced at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum here that it is dropping its decades-long resistance to opening the archives in the town of Bad Arolsen!. The files stretch for more than 15 miles, hold up to 50 million documents and make up one of the largest Holocaust archives in the world!.
"We now agree to open the data in Bad Arolsen," the German Justice Minister, Brigitte Zypries, said at a news conference here!. She said Germany would seek revision of an 11-nation arrangement that governs the archives!.



I realize that those who deny such events (or even minimize them) will not be affected by what I write here, but it is an absolute truism that when such events are disregarded, they will happen again!.

It is the responsibility for all people to not depend on what is said here (including my words) but rather dig into the sources yourself, they are available to all people!. Make your own conclusions!. Then, when others make these denial statements or minimize these events, don't let them get away with it, speak up!. If you don't it is a compromise with the same mind set that allowed these things to happen in the past!.
Www@QuestionHome@Com

As mentioned above, the Nazis were ace record-keepers, so we have evidence that way!. We also have testimony from SS leaders like Adolf Eichmann, who admitted that the "final solution" had killed more than 6 million Jews along with millions of people of other ethnic and religious groups and political dissenters!.

If you haven't heard Russians talk about their suffering during WWII, then you're not reading/listening to the right sources!. Pick up a book about the Russian liberation of Poland and eastern Germany!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

Oh dear, I'm trying hard not to react accordingly to your question, but it is very hard not to!.

At one site, in one corner, one guy tested one bit of concrete!.!.!.!. so the whole thing never happened!?

What an insult to all the 1000's who died at these places!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

My grandparents, God rest their souls, witnessed it first hand!. My grandma was Jewish and my grandpa was in Poland at the time of the invasion!. Plenty of stories but few that they were comfortable talking about!. That is more than enough proof for me!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

This is the trick of the historical revisionists and conspiracy theorists - come to a conclusion first, them do research to prove the point!.

True historians do it the other way around!.
Www@QuestionHome@Com

i think you can be pretty sure the holocaust happened, and bear in mind the gas was delivered into the chambers in the form of pellitsWww@QuestionHome@Com

look at the evidence 10,000s of people maybe more were slaughtered,how do u explain that,that would be an insult to the jews and many more,dont believe everything u c on the teleWww@QuestionHome@Com

No it certainly was not a lie!. Even the German people Know/believe it to be true!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

was your birth a lie!? maybe you are not who you think you are!. Your ID's and birth certificate and social security all liesWww@QuestionHome@Com

Of course it happened!.

Holocaust denial is ridiculous and anti-semetic!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

no,it was not a lie and those that lived through it know it was no lie or fairy tale!.Www@QuestionHome@Com

There are too many eye witness accounts for it not to have been realWww@QuestionHome@Com

that was probably only a few camps which DIDNT use gas chambers etcWww@QuestionHome@Com

NoWww@QuestionHome@Com

i don't think they could trick everyone in the world into believing that -!.- don't believe everything you hear on tvWww@QuestionHome@Com

only a complete brain dead idiot would believe that it never happened,Www@QuestionHome@Com

I dont think it would have been publicised as much as it has if it wasnt true, there must be some evidence plus the holocaust survivors would be able to tell you!.

Good question though!. You never know the truth these days!. But iw ouldnt say its a lie , there must be some truth in it , whether its been blow out of proportion or not!.

Why would people lie about something so sensitive!?Www@QuestionHome@Com