Question Home

Position:Home>History> I have to correct this utter rubbish in post by 'Don't Want Best Answer&


Question:Here is what she posted:

by Don't want best answer!!

Member since:
February 14, 2007

Another interesting tid bit for you, Hitler's own Mother was a Jew by birth, so that made him 1/2 Jew himself!

CORRECTION

- this is utter DRIVEL. Hitler did NOT have any Jewish family. The number of historians who have thoroughly investigated this is impressive and every single one has categorically stated: Hitler had NO JEWISH RELATIVES.

Perhaps some people should have the decency to check their basic 'facts' before posting.


Best Answer - Chosen by Asker: Here is what she posted:

by Don't want best answer!!

Member since:
February 14, 2007

Another interesting tid bit for you, Hitler's own Mother was a Jew by birth, so that made him 1/2 Jew himself!

CORRECTION

- this is utter DRIVEL. Hitler did NOT have any Jewish family. The number of historians who have thoroughly investigated this is impressive and every single one has categorically stated: Hitler had NO JEWISH RELATIVES.

Perhaps some people should have the decency to check their basic 'facts' before posting.

Many people don't like to hear about the Holocaust because it happened in a Christian culture. They do everything possible to blame the Jews for their own demise. They also say "real" Christians didn't cause the Holocaust. They complain because they are "inundated" with Holocaust stories -- why don't they (Jews) just "get over it." (As if Christians have gotten over the death of ONE Jew 2000 years ago.)

The truth of it is that it was probably the economy that caused the Holocaust, but it was "real" Christians who ALLOWED it to happen by either participating enthusiastically or by standing by indifferently while their neighbors' blood was being shed.

Eveyone loves to condemn the Muslims for their extreme violence, but how many remember the VERY recent violence in Christian Europe. Perhaps Christianity should rethink their phrase "love your neighbor" and change it to "HELP your neighbor." Perhaps a religion of action rather than belief is the more ethical religion.
.

So people from judia are not called 'Jus', or 'Jews' as we now know them? What else are they called? As i said, if you are speaking religiously then no, they are not a nation of people, but there was a region called Judia. So sorry - you're wrong matey. Report It

rz1971's Avatar rz1971
I wouldn't call Nazi Germany a 'Christian Culture'. Report It

mama_pajama_1's Avatar mama_paj...
Karra, I hope you are still in school and I hope you avail yourself of an education on the words nation, state and country.
The Jewish people are a nation bound by a covenant of religion.
rz..the Nazi Party Platform had a CLAUSE in the official party platform for support of positive Christianity. Report It


Other Answers (5)




="shown">
  • Princess Madeline big sib of 3's Avatar by Princess Madeline big sib of 3
    Member since:
    December 18, 2007
    Total points:
    993 (Level 2)

    ="network">
  • Add to My Contacts
  • Block User

  • Oh.

    I believed that too....

    *sweatdrop*

    okay so what's your question?

    No, you don't.

    Your posting this just means even more people will see it.

    Plus, you don't bother to go into the rumors of his jewish blood, let alone dispelling or proving them. The claims have been out there for years.

    You also don't bother to name any of the historians that back up your side of the discussion, so all you've really done is personally deny the original posters claim.

    So, no you don't need to post this, as it was barely worth my time to type an answer. The original post wasn't a real question and neither is yours.

    Was Hitler Jewish?

    One of the most frequently asked questions we receive is whether Adolf Hitler was Jewish or had ancestors who were. The idea seems to arise from the remote possibility that Hitler's grandfather was Jewish. Hitler's father, Alois, was registered as an illegitimate child with no father. Alois' mother worked in the home of a wealthy Jew and there is some chance a son in that household got the woman (i.e., Hitler's grandmother) pregnant. Adolf Hitler was not Jewish.

    Source: John Toland, Adolf Hitler, NY: Anchor Books, 1992.

    History research is about finding the evidence, but keeping an open mind to the possibilites of either side of an arguement until that evidence emerges. WW2 is not my chosen strong point in my research and so i know very little, but from what i have seen
    neither side can so far show anyone actual documented evidence, whether it be birth certificates, signed documents or even a family photo, to prove conclusively that Hitler was part Jewish. Therefore i respect both sides of this arguement and concede that you both may or may not be right.

    There is a bad habit on this website of people spouting off about their supposed knowledge, yet when asked for evidence they either go silent or on the defensive. It's just part of history - you can't presume to know what a society or person did unless you have the proof.

    Now this is not a dig at the asker here, it is a general statement, because as a neutral entity here I agree with the asker. But I am also compelled to agree with the person she mentions, until someone shows me something i can accept as evidence.